Jane Austen Summer Program
Georgian Fangirls: Women, Castrati, and Gender in Late 18th Century London | Jeffrey Nigro
Italian opera in the 18th century, whether in Italy or London, was dominated by the castrati, male-identified singers who had been castrated before puberty to preserve their treble voices. With their haunting timbres and spectacular vocal techniques, the castrati were the superstars of their time. Among their most devoted admirers were women; it was well known, or salaciously assumed, that women were attracted to castrati because they were "safe" lovers, still capable of sexual activity but without the consequences of unwanted pregnancies. But the writings and experiences of these female fans reveal a more sophisticated appreciation of the artistry of their favorite singers, a blend of connoisseurship and enthusiasm that allowed for intellectual and emotional outlets that were not always available to women at the time.
By the later 18th century the castrato phenomenon was beginning to wain, due to a number of factors: the rise of Enlightenment rationality that found the practice "barbaric"; the shift towards a more binary notion of gender; and changing operatic tastes. Yet at a time when castrati were increasingly viewed as "freaks", their female fans continued to admire and respect their artistry.
This presentation will focus on the relationships between two late-18th century castrati and the women who admired them: that of Gaspare Pacchierotti with the novelist Frances Burney and her sister, the diarist Susan Burney Phillips; and that of Luigi Marchesi with the visual artist Maria Hadfield Cosway. By studying these relationships, we have an opportunity to treat fandom, and especially women's fandom, with the respect it deserves.
Jeffrey Nigro has had a professional relationship with the Art Institute of Chicago for over 30 years, including serving as Director of Adult Programs in the Department of Museum Education from 2003 to 2010. Jeff is currently a Research Associate in the Arts of Greece, Rome, and Byzantium and an Adjunct Lecturer in the Department of Interpretation at the Art Institute. He also teaches Adult Education Seminars at the Newberry Library, and he is a former Regional Coordinator of the Greater Chicago region of JASNA. His essay, "Georgian Fangirls: Women and Castrati in 18th-Century London" appears in Women and Music in the Age of Austen, edited by Linda Zionkowski and Miriam Hart (Bucknell University Press, 2023).